In ‘A Vineyard Valentine‘, Lorelai quite enjoys her cucumber water during her “workout”, saying “What is it about cucumber water that makes it so much more refreshing than non-cucumber water?” However, if you hark back to ‘There’s the Rub’, Lorelai, perhaps more in character with her anti-vegetable policy, had a contrary reaction to cucumber water: “cucumber water. Yuck.”
Which do you think more likely to be Lorelai’s true reaction? Was this a writing mistake, or did Lorelai only dislike cucumber water at first because Emily was forcing it on her at the spa?
Watch this episode of Gilmore Girls on TheWB.com here.